While one may or may not agree with the terminology employed by the Home Minister
in his recent speech at Jaipur, we feel that for long prejudice has ruled
investigations, obscuring the role of organizations and their multiple
affiliates in planning and executing of attacks and bombings in the country.
The veneer of 'nationalism' -- narrow, exclusionary and based on hatred for
minorities as it is-- cannot hide the violence that Sangh and its affiliates
beget and peddle.
Civil rights groups have been arguing for long that the investigations into bomb
blasts and terror attacks have degenerated into communal witch-hunts. Bomb
blasts are followed predictably by mass arrests of Muslim youth, raids in
Muslim-dominated localities, detentions, arrests and torture; media trials,
charge sheets and prosecution based on custodial confessions and little real
evidence. It has been assumed, and accepted widely, that no further proof of
guilt need be offered than the fact that the accused belonged to a particular
community. Leads which pointed to the hands of groups affiliated to Sangh
organisations and their complicity in planning and executing acts of terror
were ignored, never seriously pursued. The agencies, showing their abject bias,
instead chose to pursue the beaten track of investigating Islamic terrorist
organizations such—despite clear evidence pointing in the opposite direction.
This was true of Nanded blasts in 2006, as well as of Mecca Masjid and Ajmer
Sharif bombings.
The only exception was Maharashtra ATS chief Hemant Karkare, who had, as far
back as 2008 conclusively brought into the public domain the nefarious designs
of Abhinav Bharat and its foot soldiers of hate: (Sadhvi) Pragya Singh of the
ABVP, serving army officer Col. Purohit, and Sunil Joshi, Indresh and Swami
Aseemanand belonging to the RSS. Karkare had communicated to the Hyderabad
Police the sensational claim by Col. Purohit that he had procured RDX from an
army inventory when he was posted in Jammu
and Kashmir in 2006. The Hyderabad Police however
ignored his messages, having already detained close to 70 youth belonging to
the Muslim community.
We demand that:
· Although the Indian government has belatedly
acknowledged the heinous terrorist acts of the Sangh groups we feel that a
genuine probe must also perforce encompass a thorough enquiry into the terror
nexus straddling Abhinav Bharat, RSS, VHP, BJP and Bajrang Dal leaders together
with sections of the Indian intelligence and security agencies who deliberately
subverted the probes as well as the due process of law.
· It must also be investigated whether the network of
Hindutva terrorists have been provided not just political but also financial
and logistical support by various governments
· There must be a thorough investigation into the
foreign sources of funding of the Hindutva organizations.
We hope that the acknowledgement of Hindutva terror will not remain a statement
only but that the investigations will be seriously and sincerely pursued.
Signatories
1. Manisha Sethi, Jamia Teachers’ Solidarity Association
2. Shabnam Hashmi, Act Now for Harmony and Democracy
(ANHAD)
3. Mahtab Alam, People’s Union of Civil Liberties (PUCL)
4. Mansi Sharma, Activist, Delhi
5. Subhash Gatade, Activist and Author, Godse's Children:
Hindutva
Terror in India
6. Rajeev Yadav, Adv. Mohd. Shoaib and Shahnawaz Alam,
Rihai Manch, UP
7. Amit sen Gupta, Senior Journalist, Delhi
8. Abu Zafar, Journalist, Delhi
9. Harsh Kapoor, South Asian Citizens Web
10. Seema Mustafa, Senior Journalist, Delhi
11. Ram Puniyani, Activist and Author, Mumbai
12. Sukumar Muralidharan, Senior Journalist
13. Syed Zafar Mehdi, Journalist
14. Dr. John Dayal, All India
Christian Council
15. Prof. Kamal Mitra Chenoy, JNU
16. Navaid Hamid, Member, National Integration Council, GoI
17. Prof Anuradha Chenoy, JNU
18. Saba Naqvi, Senior Journalist, Delhi
19. Wilfred Dcosta, Indian Social Action Forum (INSAF)
20. Harsh Dobhal, Human Rights Law Network (HRLN)
21. Kaviata Krishnan, All India
Progressive Women Association (AIPWA)
2
Action against Communal Politics: Call for Impartial and Appropriate Action
We the undersigned are concerned by the developments in Andhra Pradesh following the alleged hate speech by Mr. Akberuddin Owaisi recently. Many groups and organisations including many of the undersigned had condemned the speech and demanded action and also against members of some Hindutva organisations who were engaging in similar activities.
There were many instances of hate speeches and communal instigations by leaders and members of different communities in the past but the government had failed to take appropriate action in time and thereby encouraged such behavior by these divisive groups.
Even in the present case of the speech by Mr. Akberuddin Owaise, the government did not act immediately and when it did act, a number of Sections including a very grave charge under Sec.121 that deals with sedition against the state and can result in death penalty or life imprisonment were booked against him. It is unwarranted to charge him under such very serious sections. Further, Mr. Asaduddin Owaisi, MP, has also been arrested in an old case dating from 2005 and his bail plea has been rejected twice.
The total silence of the government for years in these matters and the sudden action in bringing up old cases and slapping of serious charges, especially in the context of the recent withdrawal of support by MIM to the Congress Government in the State is sending a very wrong message to the people that this is going beyond the requirements of justice and is being influenced by vendetta politics. The matter becomes more sensitive when they are representatives of the people elected through the democratic process.
We urge that any action by the government in all such matters should be immediate, impartial and commensurate with the aberration committed, otherwise it will be seen as victimization, spread disenchantment within the affected communities, polarise people and could result in social unrest and violence.
Hence, in the interest of justice and prevention of further polarisation that could have disastrous consequences for social stability and proper inter community relations, we urge the government to desist from any actions that appear vindictive and unjust or directed only against a particular community and undertake all and only such actions that are impartial and appropriate to secure justice. All people, irrespective of the community to which they belong would also welcome and endorse such actions and there would be no danger of any social disenchantment.
Dr. Asghar Ali Engineer- Mumbai
Mahesh Bhatt- Mumbai
Praful Bidwai- New Delhi
Dr. Mazher Hussain- Hyderabad
Dr. Ram Punyani- Mumbai
Javed Anand- Mumbai
Jeevan kumar- Hyderabad
Dr. Sandeep Panday- Lucknow
Irfan Engineer- Mumbai
Bro. Verghese- Hyderabad
Jatin Desai- Mumbai
M.J. Vijayan- New Delhi