Image

MODI and BIDEN: Unequally yoked (George Abraham)

Published on 21 June, 2023
MODI and BIDEN: Unequally yoked (George Abraham)

Last month,  in Hiroshima, Japan, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni announced in the middle of the Group of Seven (G-7) summit that she would leave the meeting a day earlier than scheduled to lead the response to flood which hit the north of her country very hard that week. Torrential rains devastated eastern parts of the Emmilia-Romagna region, killing 14 people and causing enormous damage.

Compare that to Mr. Modi, the Prime Minister of India, who is on a state visit to the United States when the state of Manipur is burning, hundreds of people are being killed, and thousands are made homeless by Hindu militants by burning the entire villages often with people inside as part of a broader agenda to ethnically cleanse the tribal people who are mostly Christians from the land they have inhabited for hundreds of years.

Mr. Modi also traveled to Australia after the Quad summit in Papua New Guinea while the Manipur mayhem was getting out of hand in the name of strengthening bilateral relations between the two countries. However, the primary discussion reported to the news media was the recent attacks on the Hindu temples in Australia. The foreign secretary Vinay Mohan Kwatra, responding to a question about the attacks, reiterated that the Indian government had made its case very clearly. "The attack on the temples and activities of the other separatist elements were also discussed by the two prime ministers earlier and today. From the discussions last time till this time, the progress is clearly reflected in the fact that PM Modi thanked PM Albanese for the action that the Govt of Australia has taken against these elements," said Kwatra.

There is absolutely nothing improper about a leader concerned about his people in foreign lands, especially for their security and safety. However, it is ironic for a man to engage in primary discussion protecting the places of worship of his own faith on a foreign land while allowing 253 churches to be torched by his supporters back home. Christian organizations in the area have recorded the burning, damage, or destruction of those churches and six Christian Institutions amid the wave of violence. Significantly, these churches primarily served as places of worship for Meitei Christians. It is alleged that these structures were primarily targeted and destroyed by Meitei Hindus. The RSS, the militant Hindu Group, is believed to be behind these attacks. One also wonders that in the middle of the fight between Meiteis and Kukis over land rights, why did the mob burn down and destroy 249 churches in the Meitei heartland in the first wave of violence?

Mr. Joshua Hangshing, one of the victims of this dastardly attack, said, "Mobs shouted threatening at my wife, accusing her of converting to Christianity. Moments later, she and her son Joshua were burned alive while the perpetrators rejoiced in their macabre victory. The last words of my innocent son were Papa, Papa". This ongoing violence could have been prevented within days if the government in Manipur and the Home Ministry in Delhi had acted responsibly.

In a parliamentary democracy, elections are competitive and often fought bitterly. However, once a party leader takes the oath of office, that person becomes the leader of the entire nation. However, what we are witnessing in India today contradicts that norm. Prime Minister Modi and the party he represents, BJP, may be interested only in one religious Group's welfare and appears unconcerned about its implications. The consequences are out in the open where minorities fall victim to his party's nefarious agenda pressing ahead for a majoritarian rule.

For Indian Americans, a state visit by the leader of their motherland should be a heartwarming occasion. Undoubtedly, it signifies the importance the U.S. government attaches to this relationship. They would like to see a warm relationship built on shared values and shared interests. However, the Diaspora is polarized over this overture as numerous reports indicate how the Modi administration's efforts to undermine its democratic institutions, including the judiciary, muzzling the media and driving the nation on a perilous path towards authoritarianism.

Although the Biden Administration promised to put human rights, religious freedom, and press freedom at the forefront of foreign policy, they appear to be very selective in their approach to building relationships. If America should continue to be a  shining city on a hill for all those who love freedom and liberty, President Biden should have a frank talk and sincere discussion with Prime Minister Modi urging him to uphold shared values, without which a stronger or more reliable friendship can never be achieved. Mr. President, please ask Mr. Modi why he didn't utter a word until now on the continuing bloodshed and suffering of his own people in Manipur as he readies to raise his champagne glass in the White House.

It is a sad spectacle that a good portion of the Indian Diaspora shows little or no compassion for the suffering people in Manipur. According to Arthur Schopenhauer, compassion is the basis for morality. When we restrain compassion, our moral identity is compromised. It is time to ponder that India's success as a democracy is seriously compromised by a serious deficit of compassion and a pervasive absence of integrity. India's own treatment of its vulnerable minorities is not a good indicator of the well-being of Non-resident Indians across the world, where they will not have a leg to stand on demanding fairness, equality, and justice.

Join WhatsApp News
Well-Wisher 2023-06-21 15:43:53
Very well written article. When they are politicians, no one need to have higher expectations . They pretend to do things that are just for "show". Very few leaders are genuinely concernd about their people. There are no surprises here. Mr. Biden has his problems concerning about the bribery scandel and his famous son Hunter. They lie through their teeth. Definitely, we see a "two-tier" injustce in this country. Whoever is going to be the next president, will have a tough task ahead of them. The prospect of a third world war depends on how soon a capable leader takes charge of this country.
Thomas Abraham 2023-06-21 18:58:25
George Abraham is right. Mr Biden must ask Modi if Yoga is Unity of these Nations, why the same spirit is missing in the land of his Yoga , where Minorities are under attack, Christian churches destroyed and above all the One-Man show in govt of India !! What a shame , in U S congress this dictator to speak, tolerating his yogis lies !!
Anthappan 2023-06-21 22:29:28
“This week, President Joe Biden will host Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi for a state dinner — only the third foreign leader to receive such an honor at the Biden White House, the other two being the presidents of France and South Korea. They have a lot to talk about: A White House statement on the meeting has a long list of discussion topics, including climate change and security in the Indo-Pacific region (read: countering China). But there’s a word missing from the agenda that is, arguably, the most important of all: democracy. Since Modi took office in 2014, and especially after winning reelection in 2019, he has systematically taken a hammer to the core institutions of Indian democracy. The prime minister’s government has undermined the independence of the election supervision authority, manipulated judges into ruling in his favor, used law enforcement against his enemies, and increased its control over the Indian press. The prime minister’s anti-democratic behavior has accelerated over time. In the past year alone, Modi’s government has: Expelled the leader of the opposition party, Rahul Gandhi, from parliament after he was sentenced to two years of prison for allegedly defaming the prime minister with a joke. Taken over one of the few remaining independent television stations through a crooked billionaire ally. Created an official panel empowered to take down social media posts critical of the government. Sent tax officials to raid the BBC’s offices in New Delhi and Mumbai, a move widely seen as retaliation for a documentary critical of Modi. Being in power has become self-reinforcing for Modi. His Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has used its electoral dominance to silence critics and stack the electoral deck against his opponents, making the upcoming 2024 parliamentary election a significant uphill climb for other parties. That vote is shaping up to be critical for India’s democratic future. “With every major election loss, the window might be closing” for the opposition, warns Pavithra Suryanarayan, a political scientist at the London School of Economics.”
Vayanakkaran 2023-06-22 00:11:10
Manipur is burning. Scores of people are killed ruthlessly just for belonging to another faith. Thousands of innocent citizens had to flee from home into the deep jungle. Militants have taken over the land. Smell of burning bodies and dwellings are felt everywhere. And, where is our PM who is supposed to give instructions to deal with the situation? He is practicing YOGA! We are considered as the largest ‘democracy’ in the world. But truthfully where is the democracy? It’s dictatorship. George Abraham said that very clearly. Retaliatory actions by the PM shows that. The sky over Manipur is smoky and so as our future!
Indian Christian 2023-06-22 00:30:16
BJP is the political front of RSS which has fascist ideology. RSS is a cadre entity and strives for Hindu Rashtriya for India. They have strong links with overseas Hindus. Where as, Christians in India are divided into different denominations, have no strong leadership and failed to influence the international forums. If there is any anti Hindu or Jewish incident any where in the world, their activists react with the concerned authorities.
മലയാളത്തില്‍ ടൈപ്പ് ചെയ്യാന്‍ ഇവിടെ ക്ലിക്ക് ചെയ്യുക